HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017954.jpg
1.27 MB
Extraction Summary
10
People
3
Organizations
2
Locations
2
Events
3
Relationships
4
Quotes
Document Information
Type:
Court filing (complaint/legal pleading)
File Size:
1.27 MB
Summary
This court document (Case 1:19-cv-03377) outlines evidence refuting Alan Dershowitz's defenses regarding his interactions with Jeffrey Epstein and Virginia Roberts. It cites testimony from Epstein's staff (Alessi, Rodriguez) and other victims (Ransome, Farmer), as well as flight logs and police reports, to demonstrate that Dershowitz did stay at Epstein's home, flew on his plane without his wife, and was present around young females. The text also mentions a written communication from Roberts' lawyer to Dershowitz advising that his travel records were incomplete and that he should have settled the case.
People (10)
| Name | Role | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Alan Dershowitz | Defendant/Subject of allegations |
Accused of sexual misconduct; his defenses regarding travel and presence at Epstein's properties are being refuted.
|
| Virginia Roberts (Giuffre) | Plaintiff/Victim |
Accuses Dershowitz of sexual abuse; identified him in photos.
|
| Jeffrey Epstein | Associate |
Owner of the house and plane where alleged events took place.
|
| Juan Alessi | Witness/Household Employee |
Epstein's household employee whose testimony places Dershowitz at Epstein's house.
|
| Alfredo Rodriguez | Witness/Household Employee |
Epstein's household employee whose testimony places Dershowitz at Epstein's house.
|
| Sarah Ransome | Witness |
Provided testimony contradicting Dershowitz's claims.
|
| Maria Farmer | Witness |
Provided testimony contradicting Dershowitz's claims.
|
| Nathan Myhrvold | Third Party |
The individual Dershowitz claimed Roberts confused him with.
|
| Dershowitz's Wife | Family Member |
Mentioned in context of flight logs; Dershowitz claimed he never flew without her.
|
| Roberts' Lawyer | Legal Counsel |
Communicated directly with Dershowitz regarding evidence inconsistencies.
|
Organizations (3)
| Name | Type | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Palm Beach police | ||
| FBI | ||
| House Oversight Committee (implied by Bates stamp) |
Timeline (2 events)
Unknown
Alleged sexual encounter
Unknown (context implies Epstein property)
Alan Dershowitz
Virginia Roberts
Locations (2)
Relationships (3)
Dershowitz stayed at Epstein's house and flew on his plane.
Roberts alleges she had sex with Dershowitz.
Dershowitz claimed Roberts confused him with Myhrvold; Roberts denied this.
Key Quotes (4)
"She was, and is, clear that it was Dershowitz, not Myhrvold, with whom she had sex."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017954.jpg
Quote #1
"Dershowitz’s claim he had never been on Epstein’s plane without his wife was proven false by plane logs."Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017954.jpg
Quote #2
"Roberts’ lawyer’s told Dershowitz in writing that they 'had discovered evidence inconsistent with some of [your] representations'"Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017954.jpg
Quote #3
"he 'should have settled the case when he had a chance'"Source
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017954.jpg
Quote #4
Full Extracted Text
Complete text extracted from the document (1,740 characters)
Case 1:19-cv-03377 Document 1 Filed 04/16/19 Page 20 of 28
(a) Dershowitz’s alleged backup for his travel summary proved to be incomplete and in some instances apparently altered.
(b) Dershowitz’s key claim that he had not stayed at Epstein’s house was proven false, including by the testimony of Epstein’s household employees Juan Alessi (see ¶ 56 above) and Alfredo Rodriguez (see ¶¶ 56-57 above) as well as the testimony of Sarah Ransome (Exhibit 14) and Maria Farmer (Exhibit 12).
(c) Dershowitz’s claim that Ms. Roberts confused him with Nathan Myhrvold was tested by showing Ms. Roberts pictures of both. She was, and is, clear that it was Dershowitz, not Myhrvold, with whom she had sex.
(d) Dershowitz’s claim he had never been on Epstein’s plane without his wife was proven false by plane logs.
(e) Dershowitz’s claim that he had never seen pictures of young females at Epstein’s house was proven false by Palm Beach police and FBI reports.
(f) Dershowitz’s claim that he had never been in the presence of young females was proven false by the testimony of Epstein’s household employer (see ¶¶56-57) and of young women themselves (see Exhibit 14 [Ransome] and Exhibit 12 [Farmer].)
(b) Dershowitz’s key claim that he had not stayed at Epstein’s house was proven false, including by the testimony of Epstein’s household employees Juan Alessi (see ¶ 56 above) and Alfredo Rodriguez (see ¶¶ 56-57 above) as well as the testimony of Sarah Ransome (Exhibit 14) and Maria Farmer (Exhibit 12).
(c) Dershowitz’s claim that Ms. Roberts confused him with Nathan Myhrvold was tested by showing Ms. Roberts pictures of both. She was, and is, clear that it was Dershowitz, not Myhrvold, with whom she had sex.
(d) Dershowitz’s claim he had never been on Epstein’s plane without his wife was proven false by plane logs.
(e) Dershowitz’s claim that he had never seen pictures of young females at Epstein’s house was proven false by Palm Beach police and FBI reports.
(f) Dershowitz’s claim that he had never been in the presence of young females was proven false by the testimony of Epstein’s household employer (see ¶¶56-57) and of young women themselves (see Exhibit 14 [Ransome] and Exhibit 12 [Farmer].)
73. After Dershowitz’s claimed proof of exonerating evidence collapsed, and the evidence of his guilt grew, Roberts’ lawyer’s told Dershowitz in writing that they “had discovered evidence inconsistent with some of [your] representations”, that his travel “records were incomplete”, and that he “should have settled the case when he had a chance”.
74. Roberts’ lawyer explicitly told Dershowitz that neither Roberts nor her lawyer would make any statement saying or implying that Roberts was mistaken in her charge that
20
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017954
Discussion 0
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document