DOJ-OGR-00017199.jpg
647 KB
Extraction Summary
9
People
1
Organizations
1
Locations
3
Events
4
Relationships
2
Quotes
Document Information
Type:
Legal document
File Size:
647 KB
Summary
This document is a page from a court transcript of a rebuttal argument given by Ms. Comey on August 10, 2022. She argues for the credibility of several witnesses, including Juan Alessi and the ex-boyfriends (Matt, Dave, Shawn) of other female witnesses, stating they have no motive to lie. Comey highlights corroborating evidence, such as flight records showing minors Jane and Virginia on Jeffrey Epstein's planes and Alessi's own admission of stealing from and repaying Epstein, to bolster their testimony against the defendant.
People (9)
| Name | Role | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Ms. Comey |
Mentioned in the header as the speaker of the rebuttal.
|
|
| Matt | ex-boyfriend |
Listed as one of the ex-boyfriends who testified as a witness.
|
| Dave | ex-boyfriend |
Listed as one of the ex-boyfriends who testified as a witness.
|
| Shawn | ex-boyfriend |
Listed as one of the ex-boyfriends who testified as a witness.
|
| Juan Alessi | witness |
A key witness whose testimony is being defended. He drove passengers to the tarmac and his testimony is corroborated ...
|
| Mr. Alessi | witness |
Referred to as Mr. Alessi, who admitted to stealing money from Jeffrey Epstein and paying it back.
|
| Jeffrey Epstein |
The person from whom Mr. Alessi stole money. His planes were used to fly minors.
|
|
| Jane | passenger |
Mentioned as a minor who flew on Epstein's planes, confirmed by flight records.
|
| Virginia | passenger |
Mentioned as a minor who flew on Epstein's planes, confirmed by flight records.
|
Organizations (1)
| Name | Type | Context |
|---|---|---|
| SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. | company |
Listed at the bottom of the page, likely the court reporting service.
|
Timeline (3 events)
Witnesses, including ex-boyfriends Matt, Dave, and Shawn, and Juan Alessi, testified in court.
court
Jane and Virginia flew on Epstein's planes when they were minors.
Epstein's planes
Locations (1)
| Location | Context |
|---|---|
|
Juan Alessi is said to have driven passengers up to the tarmac.
|
Relationships (4)
Mr. Alessi stole money from Jeffrey Epstein and paid it back. He also worked in a capacity that involved driving passengers for Epstein's planes.
Referred to as one of the 'ex-boyfriends' of the women who are witnesses.
Referred to as one of the 'ex-boyfriends' of the women who are witnesses.
Referred to as one of the 'ex-boyfriends' of the women who are witnesses.
Key Quotes (2)
"Remember, Mr. Alessi told you himself he stole money from Jeffrey Epstein and he paid it back."Source
— Ms. Comey
(Used to argue that Alessi's honesty about his own past wrongdoing makes his testimony about the defendant more credible.)
DOJ-OGR-00017199.jpg
Quote #1
"Flight records confirmed that Jane and Virginia flew on Epstein's planes when they were minors, just like he told you."Source
— Ms. Comey
(Presented as corroborating evidence that supports the testimony of a witness (presumably Juan Alessi).)
DOJ-OGR-00017199.jpg
Quote #2
Full Extracted Text
Complete text extracted from the document (1,602 characters)
Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 767 Filed 08/10/22 Page 178 of 257
LCKVMAX8
Rebuttal - Ms. Comey
LCKVMAX8
Rebuttal - Ms. Comey
have just stacked lie on top of lie on top of lie. That
doesn't make any sense for a whole host of reasons.
First, if these women are lying, then that means all
of the witnesses who backed them up are lying too. The
ex-boyfriends, Matt, Dave, Shawn, they must be lying. Juan
Alessi must be lying. That's simply nonsensical for the
ex-boyfriends. Matt, Dave, and Shawn have nothing to gain from
testifying here. They have no reason whatsoever to lie. No
motive. Why would they come here and lie to you?
The same goes for Juan Alessi. The defense spent a
lot of time trying to dirty Alessi up. You know why they did
that? It's because his testimony is incredibly powerful
evidence that backs up so much of what these other witnesses
say. But their arguments about him are really just silly.
They spent time talking about the money and the gun.
Remember, Mr. Alessi told you himself he stole money
from Jeffrey Epstein and he paid it back. Some police report
says that he was also looking for a gun. So what? Does that
mean that he would make up an entire story about the defendant?
No. And you know he told you the truth because he was
corroborated by other evidence. Flight records confirmed that
Jane and Virginia flew on Epstein's planes when they were
minors, just like he told you. The pilots confirmed that Juan
Alessi drove passengers up to the tarmac, just like he told
you. The household manual showed you in black and white that
doesn't make any sense for a whole host of reasons.
First, if these women are lying, then that means all
of the witnesses who backed them up are lying too. The
ex-boyfriends, Matt, Dave, Shawn, they must be lying. Juan
Alessi must be lying. That's simply nonsensical for the
ex-boyfriends. Matt, Dave, and Shawn have nothing to gain from
testifying here. They have no reason whatsoever to lie. No
motive. Why would they come here and lie to you?
The same goes for Juan Alessi. The defense spent a
lot of time trying to dirty Alessi up. You know why they did
that? It's because his testimony is incredibly powerful
evidence that backs up so much of what these other witnesses
say. But their arguments about him are really just silly.
They spent time talking about the money and the gun.
Remember, Mr. Alessi told you himself he stole money
from Jeffrey Epstein and he paid it back. Some police report
says that he was also looking for a gun. So what? Does that
mean that he would make up an entire story about the defendant?
No. And you know he told you the truth because he was
corroborated by other evidence. Flight records confirmed that
Jane and Virginia flew on Epstein's planes when they were
minors, just like he told you. The pilots confirmed that Juan
Alessi drove passengers up to the tarmac, just like he told
you. The household manual showed you in black and white that
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
(212) 805-0300
(212) 805-0300
DOJ-OGR-00017199
Discussion 0
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this epstein document